Monday, 2 November 2015

La Liberté d’Imaginer: La Nécessité d’agir

‘’WHAT’S PAST IS PROLOGUE’’


I used to worry that what I write today might be at odds with what I wrote six or 12 months ago; now I worry that what I write today might not be at odds with what I wrote six or 12 months ago. The point being that the world moves on, and the world of healthcare quality and safety moves on with it…or even faster. I also think that we all have a prerogative, perhaps even a responsibility, to change our minds, to shift our positions. In politics, if it were not for the so called ‘’swinging voters’’ there would never be changes of government and we would all be the worse for that.

So, after I finish this BLOG I do not propose to check that my thoughts today align with my thoughts of yesterday.

Hence my theme.




China’s President recently visited Great Britain and much fuss was made of the visit. In his address to a joint sitting of the Commons and the Lords, President, Xi Jinping, quoted Shakespeare, specifically The Tempest Act II Scene 1 in which Antonio is trying to persuade Sebastien to kill his father the King so Sebastien can be crowned……. ‘What’s past is prologue’, he says to the impressionable Sebastien, his point being that what has gone before creates an inevitability about what we must now do………all that has gone before is just preparation for what must be a different future.

While we might not like what Antonio was up to, his rationale is ‘right on’ when it comes to healthcare and the future we face.

If we just ‘keep on keeping on’ in healthcare we will:
  • Run out of money
  • Age unhealthily
  • Have to make frightening choices as a society and as individuals about who we treat and who we do not. For instance, it may be that a child born today will only live past 70 if he/she remains well, we may choose to treat only the so called ‘productive members of society’ with our limited resources rather than those not creating wealth.
  • Fail to apply the latest treatments and technologies.
  • Miss the whole point of the patient journey and patient centered care.
  • Continue to try and make sick people, usually acutely sick people, well instead of stopping them getting sick in the first place.
Rather than go on, let me summarise the paradigm shift that is necessary if we are going to have any hope of making healthcare delivery possible in the future and of continuing to deliver safe, affordable quality care.

Frost & Sullivan

Or as Professor Angela Brand, Coordinator of the Public Health Genomics European Network (PHGEN) at the University of Maastricht and Director of the European Center for Public Health Genomics puts it, the basic building blocks of future medicine will be:

Predictive = predicting disease

Pre-emptive = preventing diseases

Personalised = highly precise personalised diagnosis and treatment

Participatory = patients play an active decision-making role in their health care.

I will reciprocate President, Xi Jinping quoting Shakespeare by quoting a Chinese proverb:
前人栽树,后人乘凉 “One generation plants the trees, another enjoys the shade”

Well, where healthcare delivery and healthcare quality and safety is concerned we had better start planting some forests because time is running out.

There are a number of reasons for us reaching this current position, where we are clearly heading for a fall, and soon.

One is the tyranny of the political cycle.

When did you last see a politician make a decision about anything that did not have a direct bearing on returning her/him to office in an election just months away? So it is not surprising that in the lead up to an election politicians focus on visible and popular themes like reducing waiting lists. Noble enough a quest, but the way they do this is by throwing money at half-baked schemes that might impact until after the next election then everything falls back in a heap. How do you really reduce waiting lists?………preventative medicine, stop people getting sick in the first place. BUT, that is not what the public, aka voters, want to hear because it will not impact for maybe two decades. BUT WHEN IT DOES IT WILL BE A CURE, PERMANENT, NOT A QUICK FIX OR BANDAID.

So how do we break this insidious cycle?

Is it possible to contemplate healthcare policy being formulated independently of politics? By a statutory body perhaps? But this usurps the proper political process, doesn’t it? Desperate times call for desperate measures and I am not overstating how desperate the future of healthcare delivery is if we do not take bold steps. If we do not remove healthcare policy from politicians we will need bipartisanship to achieve any serious long-term future planning and given the, by and large, schoolyard approach of politicians to any sense of bipartisanship, I wouldn’t be holding my breath on this one. The problem is, removing any major program from the political arena and placing it in the hands of an appointed rather than elected forum starts to erode the very tenets of democracy.

So, if the partisan politicians are incapable of taking a longer term approach to remodelling healthcare, if bipartisanship is highly unlikely, and if a statutory approach starts to look like dictatorial control, where does that leave us? Perhaps it is up to bodies like ISQua and the organisations to which you belong and to you and me to continue to fight the good fight and hope for a miracle.

Peter Carter
Chief Executive Officer
November 2015







Friday, 24 July 2015

"La liberté pour Rêver"


“Health is an eternal theme of humanity – and a strong, healthy and sustainable society is our common pursuit. So let us dream, but then let us return here to earth to do the work that is needed to attain health and harmony at home." Minister Chen Zhu, Minister of Health, China, 2013.” (2)

‘Opening a window to the future….
It is a warm Wednesday in January 2050 in Santiago. The newscaster is reporting the latest performance figures for the city, and Ana frowns as she hears that wellbeing and air quality have both dropped a few points. In the centenary year of the landmark Doll and Hill study on smoking and lung cancer this is not good for public relations! She makes a mental note to discuss this with the City Forum later in the day. For now she has to prepare for a visiting delegation from Tokyo, Lagos and Los Angeles who have come to finalise the protocol connecting the electronic data and remote sensing systems for maintaining population health across their megacities. Ana has kept in touch with them online in the peer to peer learning platform as they all connected years ago to the same cyber‐ engineer supporting their 3D vaccine printers. With Saito from Tokyo, Meng from Lagos and Raul from Los Angeles she had many long debates over the years on issues ranging from how to rebuild solidarity, to what the priorities should be for planetary health. She can’t wait to see them again!’ (2)

Opening a window to the present….
It is a warm Wednesday in ‘outback’ Australia, 2015.  A world away from Santiago 2050. The sheep are ‘full wool’ and need to be shorn. The air is pure and fresh and the skies are clear.

So what brings us from the bucolic ‘outback’ scene to the apparently inevitable and inexorable journey to the perils of 2050? Many things and they impact both directly and indirectly on healthcare.

Chief amongst them is the ageing of the population. This does not just burden healthcare and healthcare resources directly but indirectly as it places pressure on the environment – where in the future will water come from, what will we breathe if we have no forests and if the atmosphere we live in is dense with harmful chemicals?

We face a future characterised as follows:
  • ‘We will live longer lives, with greater possibilities for healthy ageing’ (but a danger of unhealthy ageing). ‘; 
  • We will be more urbanised and interact more with artificial intelligence;
  • Climate change and scarcities of energy, water, biodiversity and food will have a fundamental impact on health and survival;
  • Science and technology will advance rapidly, with linkages across information, robotic, health and bio- technologies, profoundly affecting public health and medicine’.
Amongst the ominous, good things are happening:
  • “In Bangladesh, continuous lifelong, portable, electronic health records are being developed based on unique biometric identifiers assigned at birth as part of universal vital events and health information systems”. Dr Tim Evans, James Grant School of Public Health, Bangladesh
  •  “In Shanghai they have community-based self-help groups organized with government input that help each other in terms of learning how to control their blood pressure and blood sugars, how to live a healthier life, group exercise etc. I think we need more innovative ways to deal with ageing.” Meeting delegate, January 2013 
  • “We need to put health not only in the hands of doctors, nurses, pharmacists or dentists- like many of us here, including me - but health must also be in the hand of the active citizen.” Suwit Wibulpolprasert, Ministry of Public Health Thailand, 2013 (2)
But progress is uneven and dependent on visionary individuals or teams.
  • ‘Large, centralized institutions with top-down, expert-driven thinking may not be the only, or best sites for the ideas, leadership and action for health futures’. (2)
So all this leads me to ISQua’s own humble attempts to shift world thinking about how to shape our healthcare future. In two months a group made up of the world’s big thinkers and clever thinkers will tackle this problem. The ISQua Innovations and Systems Change Working Group has invited these people to take part in a workshop at the ISQua Annual International Conference to talk about shaping the future of healthcare.

There will be around 30 in all brought together for a day to share information about how their various countries and people are understanding and planning for the inevitability that if we keep delivering healthcare the way we are currently delivering it the system will crumble under the weight of an ageing population with expensive comorbidities and a deteriorating environment. We will be faced with unpleasant and unthinkable choices such as who to treat and who to leave untreated. But the option of not thinking about these things is not open to us.

In addition to gathering information of how healthcare is delivered in different countries and innovative approaches to this, amongst the questions to be addressed are:

1. Does your government and do your healthcare authorities recognise an ageing population as posing a threat to future generations’ wellbeing?

2. Do you consider the ageing of the population to be a problem in your country? If so how will this manifest itself in your context? If not a problem why is it not so?

3. What are the consequences of the ageing of the population in your part of the world?

4. What if any steps are being taken by government and healthcare authorities in your country to address the problems of an ageing population?

5. Do you consider the steps being taken to be appropriate/adequate (if not, why not)? How might you approach this differently?

6. Is there any recognition in your country of ‘the patient journey’ as a means of improving healthcare quality and redistributing the cost burden?

7. Is it sustainable to continue to focus on hospital care as a means of addressing healthcare needs, especially in the light of the ageing population? What are the alternatives?

8. Would a shift to a primary care focus (or homecare focus) ameliorate the burden imposed on healthcare delivery as the population ages?

9. What do you see as possible solutions to the future challenges facing healthcare?

The future cannot be the same as the past.
We must start to address these issues now before we are so overburdened and overwhelmed by the immediacy of the problems that will surely come that we are powerless to deal with them.

The work we do now may ameliorate the problems for us but, importantly, may provide a better future for the people of 2050 such as those in Santiago we were introduced to at the beginning of this story.

前人栽树,后人乘凉 “One generation plants the trees, another enjoys the shade” Chinese proverb.

Peter Carter
Chief Executive Officer
July 2015

References
(1) "La liberté pour Rêver" and "La liberté pour parler" are essays written in French by French Nobel laureate J. M. G. Le Clézioand translated into English as "Freedom to Dream" and "Freedom to Speak" and published by World Literature Today .
(2) Dreaming the Future of Health for the Next 100 Years White paper from the Global Health Summit Beijing China, January 26-27 2013

Friday, 5 June 2015

Views

Education must be not only a transmission of culture, but also a provider of alternative views of the world and a strengthener of the will to explore them.
Jerome Bruner

This is the view across the Dublin skyline from my office window. Dublin is a low-rise city.
Describe to me what you see.

I asked a number of my staff to do this and no two descriptions were the same…in fact no two descriptions were remotely alike. What we see when we look at a view is a product of many things including:


  • What we are doing at the time;
  • How much time we have to dwell on the view;
  • What’s on our mind;
  • How we woke up that morning;
  • Our upbringing;
  • Our education; and 
  • What we are looking for.


In the case of one of my staff it was a case of ‘What’s he on about now!?’ When I explained it was an exercise in preparing me for my BLOG all was forgiven (maybe not!).

In this view I see history; values; economics; political impulses; imperatives; restraints; constraints; hope and hopelessness. I also see beauty and ugliness.

The humble community housing in the foreground, named in honour of one of the heroines of the 1916 Easter Rising, Countess Markievicz, is overshadowed just a few blocks beyond by the glass edifices of the Ulster Bank HQ – a legacy of the Celtic Tiger years of excess. Just out of shot to the left is one of the world’s most prestigious universities, Trinity College and in the shadow of Trinity is the house in which Oscar Wilde was born. Just out of shot to the right is the Sean O’Casey Bridge over the River Liffey, which is a fitting tribute to the writer who had his own take on life:

I have found life an enjoyable, enchanting, active, and sometime terrifying experience, and I've enjoyed it completely. A lament in one ear, maybe, but always a song in the other.

And then, not such a fitting tribute to another great Irish writer is the building from which this photograph was taken, which houses the ISQua Offices, Joyce House, which would be an appropriate honour for the great man if the building had any prepossessing or redeeming features which, alas, it does not. Then Joyce himself had quite a different view on life:

“All Moanday, Tearday, Wailsday, Thumpsday, Frightday, Shatterday.” 


I could understand Joyce feeling this way if he ever had to live in Joyce House.

So, where is this all leading?
I think it is celebrating diversity. The Irish have become good at that in recent times having been not so good at in the past – witness a plebiscite on Gay Marriage a few weeks ago that was carried by a majority of over 62%. Yet, even when divorce and contraception was illegal in Ireland, not so long ago, Ireland, as always, was producing permissive writers such as the aforementioned Wilde, Casey and Joyce.

This BLOG is getting away from me a little and I am finding it difficult now to link it to what I want to talk to you about, being the new ISQua Vision, Mission and Values.

But, perhaps not.

Take the word ‘transformation’ in the Vision, and the Values of Transparency, Integrity and Ethical behaviour and……..wait for it……DIVERSITY.
These are nothing if not permissive values.

And why should not healthcare embody and encourage such important values. In fact, when one considers the challenges that are bearing down on healthcare now, and particularly those that will do so in the future, how can we continue to deliver high quality healthcare if we do not embody such values?

Now, what I really wanted to do with this BLOG was to issue an invitation to you. The ISQua Board needs to know what you think about the new Vision, Mission and Values before we lock them in as our guiding principles for the next three years.
I have reproduced them below in case you can’t read what is written on the staff kitchen white Board (or in case you mix them up with the Plant Watering Roster which is scribbled right next to them).

Vision
Be the leader of transformation in healthcare quality and safety globally.

Mission 
To inspire and drive improvement in the quality and safety of healthcare worldwide through education and knowledge sharing, external evaluation, supporting health systems and connecting people through global networks.

TAG Line
Inspiring and driving improvement in the quality and safety of healthcare worldwide.

Priorities 2016 – 2018
External Evaluation, Events, Education & Knowledge Sharing, Person Centred Care, Innovation, Global Regions.

Values
Transparency, Integrity, Diversity, Ethical, Excellence, Evidence Based

So please, be in touch to tell us whether you think your Society is on the right track

And the last word to Mr Wilde……
Questions are never indiscreet, answers sometimes are.

Peter Carter
June  2015



Tuesday, 7 April 2015

Message from the Cheap Seats

Margaret Thatcher did not leave us too many quotable quotes over which to marvel down the years but there is one that is particularly memorable.

When asked about being powerful, Baroness Thatcher said:
‘Being powerful is like being a lady; if you have to tell people you are, you’re not’.

It is the same for those who tell people they are ‘a visionary’, ‘a supermodel’, ‘a leader’, ‘a thinker’.

Believe me, if you are these things we (in the cheap seats) will know. If you feel a need to tell us you are something special, it is almost certain you are not.

The Beatles never described themselves as a ‘supergroup’, others did that. But when hit with a UK Supertax on their earnings George wryly observed, ‘since we have been told we must pay a supertax then maybe we are a supergroup!’ Then he went off to write arguably his best song, ‘Taxman’ which further cemented the Beatles supergroup status.

In a classic experiment conducted in the mid-eighties, 100 undergraduates, divided into same-sex pairs, participated in two unstructured conversations spaced one week apart. In the second session, one subject of the pair was asked to participate either as an ingratiator or as a self-promoter. After the second conversation, ingratiators were rated as more likable but no more competent, and self-promoters were rated as less likable but also no more competent than in first conversation. Naive target subjects clearly recognised presenters attempting to appear competent and reacted negatively to them.

Confirmation that self-promotion doesn’t work. And what’s worse, it’s even less effective than ingratiation, and everyone hates ingratiation!

From time to time I will have a staff member who has produced an elegant piece of work complain to me that a colleague or a superior has taken credit for it. My response is: ‘Those who matter know, and those who don’t know don’t matter’ (and if this doesn’t happen through ‘Karma’, then we make sure it happens through other means!). One cannot pass oneself off as something one is not for very long and get away with it, nor can one claim someone else’s work as one’s own and get away with it. We who have been around for a while, or even if we have just arrived on the scene, know what’s what and who’s who.

A frequent question from the mentees I attempt to help with their development is ‘how do I get on’. This often includes asking me how to promote themselves. My advice is, be measured. Present yourself honestly and openly through your genuine achievements and impress people with your energy and ambition and excitement in what you are doing and what you are hoping to achieve; get out there and build a network, learn from it and give back to it. We in the cheap seats can immediately see an overstated CV or bio for what it is – inflated; the self-promotion is blindingly obvious, and CVs and bios that are written that way are quickly consigned to the waste paper basket. Similarly on websites, in blogs, on Facebook, LinkedIn and wherever, those who are trying to make a silk purse out of a sow’s ear, or to portray achievements as more than they are stand out like the ribcage of a racing Greyhound.

Maggie Thatcher did not have to tell people she was powerful, we all got that as we get that the Beatles were a supergroup; her mere presence and their wonderful music did all the talking for them.

So, relax, do your good work, we in the cheap seats will notice you and we will promote you.

Peter Carter
March 2015


Self-promotion is not ingratiating.
Godfrey, Debra K.; Jones, Edward E.; Lord, Charles G.
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, Vol 50(1), Jan 1986, 106-115.http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.50.1.106


Monday, 2 February 2015

PAPERWORK: the enemy of the Good.


The sweetest joy, the wildest woe is love. What the world really needs is more love and less paperwork.
Pearl Bailey

SO, HERE WE ARE, 2015.

I have 40,726 emails in my in-box of which 1,982 are marked as ‘unread’. I say ‘marked as unread’ because I have read them, and acted on them (I believe) but I have flagged them as unread to remind me to go back and think about them some more. In reality the likelihood that I will reread 1,982 emails and refine the action taken on at least some of them is remote to say the least. If I were to do that, by the time I finished I would have accumulated 1,982 new emails that would need to be dealt with de novo.

A British MP, desperately seeking re-election this year and trying to impress his constituents, when interviewed for a newspaper article said that each night when he got home after a long day at work, he personally answered over 400 emails. I strongly doubt that is possible, unless the MP in question suffers from Fatal Familial Insomnia. FFI is code for ‘seriously can’t sleep’. It manifests itself in hallucinations, delirium, and confusional states like that of dementia. This might explain the behaviour of more politicians than just this one. The average survival span for patients diagnosed with FFI after the onset of symptoms is 18 months. Having this condition would certainly take the worry out of contesting the next election.

Surgeon Pauline Chen, writing a piece in the New York Times claims that as much as one third of a doctor’s work day hours are spent on paperwork. How many hours does that leave for seeing patients? Only six if it is nine hour day but more likely eight or nine given the hours doctors work.

Perhaps even more worrying, however is the amount of time paperwork robs Residents of what Residents are supposed to be doing: learning through educational activities and learning by doing.

Electronic medical records and other eMed applications will change all that, right? Sadly no. Not only has the paperless office not cut down on paperwork, it has increased it and confounded it.
Increased – we exchange a staggering 10,000 times more communications than we did pre eWorld (and we print out a hell of a lot of them, despite the plea we see at the end of emails begging us not to). And that is not just because there are more of us.

Confounded – cutting and pasting was virtually impossible pre eWorld, now it is rampant in the professions with law leading the way and medicine catching up. The cutting and pasting of notes by over (paper) worked doctors is a worrying trend. A dear surgical friend of mine who was a trailblazer in eHealth told me, with great prescience in the early eDays, that the claims of a paperless office were about likely as would be claims of a paperless toilet.

Dr Chen writes: ‘Residents may rely on notes written by other doctors instead of talking to the patients themselves. These other notes may have also been pieced together from previous notes rather than from actual interactions with the patient. As a list, a paragraph or whole sections get pasted into progressively more documents, important information, like a reaction to a certain treatment, can be lost in the transfer. Clinicians who rely mostly on computer notes for their information are at risk of inadvertently choosing the wrong therapeutic course of action for a patient.’

So much for patient safety! eHealth becomes ‘eUnhealthy’.

So what can be done? Suggestions include outsourcing some of the paperwork requirements away from doctors, to support staff. This takes money. But wait, isn’t employing support staff to do paperwork at $50 per hour better than having doctors do it at $100 per hour? And, if a doc cannot see all the patients in A and E in the allotted time because of paperwork an extra doc may be put on to clear the waiting area.

Surely I should be able to put this into some type of numeric. Let me try………..

100 patients seen for 30 minutes each by one Doc at $100 an hour = $5,000

PLUS

100 patients’ notes written up at 10 minutes each by one Doc at $100 an hour = $1,667

PLUS

The 33 patients not seen while the Doc was writing up her notes which had to be seen by another Doc at $100 an hour = $1,650

PLUS

33 patients notes written up at 10 minutes each by Doc 2 at $100 an hour = $550

TOTAL $8,867

OR

133 patients seen by a Doc for 30 minutes each at $100 an hour = $6,650

PLUS

Support staff writing up notes for 133 patients for 10 minutes each at $50 an hour = $1,100

TOTAL $7,750

An add to that the fact that in the second scenario seeing the patients and note writing are taking place concurrently rather than serially so the total time taken to see 133 patients is less by about 20% which makes the patients happier and everyone can switch off the lights and go home early, thereby saving even more money.

I have simplified this for the purposes of illustration realising full well it is more complex than this. But it suggests a modus operandi that could be massaged into place with some lateral thinking and number crunching.

The other perhaps less measurable effect of paperwork on doctors, and even more so, Residents, is how demoralising paperwork can be.

I accept that Doctors need to know how to record what they see and the treatments they recommend, but today’s paperwork is way more than this. I call it ‘defensive’ paperwork. It is a bit like defensive prescribing (of medications and tests). Let’s prescribe the medication or order the test, however remote the likelihood that we are treating something you have or trying to find something you might have, in case you have it and I get sued for not finding it. All this defensive prescribing and defensive ordering of tests has to be entered in the record………..more paperwork!

Maybe there should be an agreed ‘likelihood percentage’ below which Docs are indemnified against not prescribing/ordering and against not mentioning it in the course of providing ‘informed consent’.
The incidence of hospital acquired infection is around 6% to 10% in developed countries and docs will tell you when you go for surgery that it is a risk with a likelihood of about 10% (to be on the safe side). That is fair enough even though the surgeons I have worked with tell me no patient has decided not to go for surgery because of the risk of contracting HAI. So, could 10% be the threshold above which docs should warn of the risks, order the tests, prescribe the medication and below which they can’t be sued if the risk materialises? What do you think?

That’s it from me for now. Perhaps just a few ideas to stimulate your grey matter as we launch into 2015.

NOW, back to my 1,982 unread emails……Oh Crikey!! While I have been busy writing this BLOG for you that 1,982 is now 2,246 !!

HAVE A GREAT YEAR!

Tuesday, 16 December 2014

Bah Humbug!

Now, before you get too upset that I am going to go all Ebenezer Scrooge on you, this BLOG has a happy ending.

But around about now one starts to see headlines like the one below:

Dangerous decorations, fairy light injuries and death by snow: Why Christmas is the most perilous time of the year

• One in five risks food poisoning from turkey leftovers
• Falling snow and ice kills 25 people a year
• Of the 350 reported fairy light injuries, most occurred whilst decorating
                                              By SARA MALM
                                              PUBLISHED: 04:48 GMT, 19 December 2012 | UPDATED: 07:31 GMT, 19 December 2012

And warnings about the dangers, not of Christmas itself, but associated with it. And fair enough. Christmas is one of those celebratory times of year when we do things we would not otherwise do, which, by definition suggests these are marginal activities for us; like drinking too much, eating too much, trying to do more than we should in a given period of time aka ‘rushing’, trying too hard to impress or please family and friends. In Australia, where I usually celebrate Christmas, it is common for tourists to drown in the surf, unused as they are to the wonders and whiles of the sea.

So my message to you this Christmas  is to ‘chill’ and enjoy without going ‘extreme’.

Don’t drink too much, don’t eat too much,don’t drive, definitely don’t drink AND drive, don’t go swimming, definitely don’t go swimming after eating/drinking too much, don’t stress out about right present/wrong present/ decorations/ the guest in the corner you don’t recognise (but check to see if he/she does belong to someone in the room you do know, don’t give dangerous presents (to children)……..just ‘chill’ and enjoy.

So from all of us here in the ISQua office, to all our you, who visit our website, wherever you are in the world.

SEASONS GREETINGS!



Friday, 24 October 2014

From little things big things grow.

Systems – can’t live with them; can’t live without them.


“Everything must be made as simple as possible. But not simpler.”
― Albert Einstein


My day is organised and managed in accordance with a careful plan – I have a system. The underpinnings of this system have been more or less the same for a while now.
And in one or more respects this system always fails.

Lord Darzi said in his ISQua Global Leader Lecture in May this year that from the time he awoke on the morning of the Lecture to the time he stood to deliver it he had made perhaps half a dozen errors, no doubt despite the fact he had a plan, a system in mind for the day. All were minor, none was fatal but somehow the plan was imperfect (although it may have been as good as it could have been). We all experience this all the time.

But are these our failures or has ‘the system let us down’?

In thinking about this BLOG I scribbled down the following words late one night….:
‘All systems failure is human failure – why? – because people design the systems’

This seemed so blindingly obvious and simple (simplistic as it turned out) that I immediately assumed it was a well held and oft recited view and that I had read it somewhere and it had just percolated from my sub conscious to my conscious being. But GOOGLE all I like and I could not find a quote along these lines. So, if it is not a universal veritas then perhaps it is not so (mind you, it is well to remember that, in Roman mythology, Veritas, who was the goddess of truth, a daughter of Saturn and the mother of Virtue, hid in the bottom of a holy well because she was so elusive).

So, let’s see what we can find out….

SYSTEM………the word is so widely applied and misapplied it can mean almost anything that has more than one component to it. I have lamented the misuse of words, labels and ideas in my BLOG in the past, for example, ‘tipping point’, and system is one of the most misapplied I can think of.

I considered the definition ‘A group of interacting, interrelated or interdependent elements forming a complex whole’  . This does not convey the dynamism of systems sufficiently for me.

I like even less…….  ‘A condition of harmonious, orderly action’.   Really!? Harmonious and orderly?  Some maybe.

So, I have decided to craft my own definition……….. ‘A collection of stable and dynamic elements, and tools, coordinated and managed by a process, seeking to achieve a predetermined outcome’.

So what might be a ‘health system’? That is how do we APPLY HEALTH? How do we make health happen?

Donabedien talked about ‘structure, process, outcome’.


But you and I have seen the breakdown of systems often enough to recognise their complexity. Elements act independently of the system and the system impinges on the elements within it and those bombarding it from without so the whole thing gets thrown out of whack.
‘Every intervention from the simplest to the most complex has an effect on the overall system and the overall system has an effect on every intervention.’  (de Savigny and Adam eds 2009)

This is where Systems Thinking might play a role.

‘Systems thinking works to reveal the underlying characteristics and relationships of systems’  (idem)          
But sometimes you need a miracle if you are to succeed.

Systems thinking can ‘…accelerate the strengthening of systems’  (idem) but only if it is applied with liberal doses of leadership, conviction and commitment. When used properly it can find where the blockages are and give us ideas on how to clear those blockages.

Is systems failure all down to human error at the coalface? In some cases it clearly is. The workers at the Bhopal chemical plant pumped Methyl-isocyanate into a leaking tank; the officers and crew of the Herald of Free Enterprise set to sea with their bow doors open; the Costa Concordia was deliberately diverted from her planned course at the Isola del Giglio; Night Nurse Marie misread the medication chart on the ward because she had left her reading glasses at the nurses’ station. In other cases, not so much and systems failure can be more down to managerial or organisational factors that create the pre-conditions for things to go wrong. But then I ask myself, are not deficient managerial and organisational factors man made problems?

Chris Johnson talks about management’s role as organising and managing work practices; and managerial failure being when they do this badly. He identifies another culprit though, which I think is important, and which is often overlooked; this is regulatory failure. Regulatory failure refers to the ways in which governments and other statutory bodies govern and monitor the work practices of companies and industry.

Johnson argues that the role of managerial and regulatory practices as preconditions for human error has been particularly neglected. He says most human factors and systems engineering has focussed on the immediate causes of human error and systems failure and has not looked at the organisational and regulatory context of that error, in other words, step back look at the forest as well as the trees.

‘Given the complexity of healthcare work systems and processes’……there is a need to…. ‘emphasise the need for increasing partnerships between health sciences and human factors and systems engineering to improve patient safety’ (Carayon 2010).

Transitions of care are increasing – this is a high risk process. A transition may occur within a ‘system’ or between ‘systems’. Either way they are plagued by poor communication and inconsistency in care and adverse events are a common outcome (Beach et al 2003).

Returning to Lord Darzi’s Global Leader Lecture; I was interested to hear him talk about the high correlation between one factor, being patient satisfaction/feedback, and most if not all other commonly used measures of patient safety/quality. He suggested a quick and accurate way of determining if you are doing it right is to ask the patient if you are doing it well in her or his eyes.
This is patient centered care, and it’s good because not only is it safer care but it is ‘…. care that is respectful of and responsive to individual and patient preferences, needs, values …’   and ensures ‘…patient values guide all clinical decisions’. (Institute of Medicine Committee on Quality of Health Care in America 2001).

Donabedian may have characterised health systems as structure – process – outcomes but he also referred to another important, and for him the most important ingredient. So I will let Donabedien have the last word:


“Systems awareness and systems design are important for health professionals, but they are not enough. They are enabling mechanisms only. It is the ethical dimensions of individuals that are essential to a system’s success. Ultimately, the secret of quality is love.”




Peter Carter
Chief Executive Officer
October 2014

Professor the Lord Darzi of Denham
http://www.isqua.org/education/resource-centre/lord-darzi's-global-leader-lecture

Don de Savigny; Taghreed Adam eds: Systems Think in for Health Systems Strengthening. WHO, Alliance for Health Policy and Systems Research: 2009.


C.W. Johnson, Failure in Safety-Critical Systems: A Handbook of Accident and Incident Reporting, University of Glasgow Press, Glasgow, Scotland, October 2003.



Pascale Carayon et al:  Patient Safety: The Role of Human Factors and Systems Engineering. Stud Health Technol Inform. 2010 153: 23 – 46. 

Beach C.  et al: Profiles in Patient Safety: emergency care transitions. Academic Emergency medicine. 2003; 10(4): 364-367.